Raw Meat This film portrays the Vietnam war with crude reality. You will experience how the soldiers were stressed physically and emotionally. One of the best Vietnam films I know.
better as history than as a film This is a very interesting film. It basically takes a very bloody battle from the middle of the war and recreates its from the perspective of the smallest unit on the front lines. The strength of the film is that all the events of the battle are incredibly accurate in terms of detail. The weakness of the film is that because of its "point of view", it doesn't always do a great job of explaining whats going on in the broader sense of the battle. The needed more exposition scenes in the second half of the film explaining what was going on and why things were happening. Especially from the first and second level officer's perspective.
Its interesting in that the viewer of the film not familar with the battle will see it just like the soldier on the ground saw it: a confusing mess. I'm not sure if that perspective at the cost of understanding what was going on was the right choice to make.
The only other flaw in an otherwise great movie is a bunch of political bitching about things going on at home that was tacked on at one point and sounded totally false. All those things happened to certain people, but they didn't all happen to one unit during their tour (opposed to after) and they guys didn't talk about it like they did in the film.
In terms of Vietnam films, this is with its flaws still 100x better than junk like "Platoon" or vietnam films not about vietnam like Apocolipse now. Hamburger Hill DVD Great price,fast Shipment, good communucation and the product arrived in good condition! What more could you want? Recommend this seller! Thanks!
Kevinall sorts of blood and gore and... more blood.
the first time i saw it, i was freaking out over the blood and such and it stuck with me through out high school.
i constantly told people that hamburger hill was the bloodiest war movie i ever saw ...so i bought it to refresh my memory.
that's how strong an effect it had on me.Don't mean nothing Hamburger Hill DVD
Based on my experiences, Hamburger Hill is the most realistic Viet Nam war movie that I've seen.
I was with the 25th Infantry Division in III Corps from July, 1969 to June, 1970. As I understand it the 101st airborne Division (or the "Pukin Buzzards" as the 25th called them) was to our immediate North. The few things that were not realistic were:
- I never saw a hot tub,
- We never deployed a platoon by itself, minimum Company strength.i.e. At least three [platoons.
The movie's anti-war message is apparent from the opening credits, which are interspersed with views of the Capitol and the Vietnam Memorial in Washington. The symbolism of our seat of government juxtaposed with the memorial to the fallen is heightened by the wintry sunset reflecting off the Vietnam Memorial.
Rather than a history lesson, the movie is a metaphor for the war in Vietnam: the relentless push to achieve ground of questionable importance despite the high cost in blood. Good men fought and died.
Was it worth it? As the fatalistic mantra among the grunts in the movie said, "It don't mean nothin'." That's a sad, angering attitude until you recall that shortly after the battle was over, we left the hill, as we did
Highly recommended for those who want a realistic picture of the Viet Nam war
