Add your review
Avg. Rating: 4
I must protest Call me an uncivilized peasant if you will, but I continue to despise James Joyce. I recall a college English class of mine where all the students were ducking Prof. Gatza's questions about Joyce's "Stephen Hero," and--when he solicited an explanation for the mysterious phenomenon--only fifteen-year-old Brucie Boy had the guts to tell him, "Well, none of us have read the book because, frankly, it's just pitifully wretchedly dreadful." (I suppose that's why Gatza gave me a B.) While I had high hopes, this esteemed volume did not satisfy my expectations. The "food for thought"-type supplementary material merely reinforced the point that Joyce's writings are, fundamentally, just a covert plot for ensuring that the ink and paper industries garner at least certain revenues. Oh, another thing: the typesetting and binding leaves much to be desired. The type runs far too close to the spine, meaning I had to continually crack the book more than one hundred eighty degrees open in order to avoid continual eye strain, and a few leaves had rough, fluted edges. I guess, at $4.95, you get what you pay for! Great for Teaching I decided to use this version with my AP Literature class. The notes in the back make it accessible to modern teenagers. Without the cultural and historical background provided, Joyce's stories don't have the depth for us they would have had for a contemporary reader. The literary aspect is mine to guide the students through, but I don't have to take valuable class time to teach the rest. And I sure couldn't beat the cost. As for the collection itself, not many authors are able to communicate simultaneous pathos and scorn for their subjects as is Joyce. The argument can be made that he's a bit self-victimizing, but if that's how he found his way to being able to hone in on just about every emotion a person might experience, then I can overlook the "flaw." This is my favorite Joyce. good read It took me a while to get into this book but once I did I was hooked. Great buy!
Review this book
|